What Seniors Need to Know About Florida’s Homeowners Insurance Market

If you’re a senior living in Florida—or considering a move to the Sunshine State for retirement—you’ve likely heard alarming stories about homeowners’ insurance. Headlines about skyrocketing premiums, insurance companies abandoning the state, and coverage becoming harder to find can be genuinely frightening, especially when you’re on a fixed income.

The good news? While Florida’s insurance market is indeed challenging, understanding what’s happening and knowing your options can help you make informed decisions to protect both your home and your financial security.

The Current State of Florida’s Insurance Market

Florida’s homeowners’ insurance market is experiencing unprecedented turbulence. Over the past few years, insurance premiums have increased dramatically while major insurance companies have stopped writing new policies or have left the state entirely. For a time, Citizens was the only choice for some. More recently, however, the climate is changing toward the other direction thanks to new state legislation that makes it easier for carriers to do business in the state giving homeowners more options.  

Why did rates rise and companies pull out?

Several factors have created a “perfect storm” in Florida’s insurance market:

• Increased hurricane activity and severity due to climate change
• Rising construction and repair costs for materials and labor
• Legal challenges and litigation that drive up costs for insurers
• Aging housing stock that’s more vulnerable to damage
• Population growth putting more properties at risk

For seniors, this situation is particularly concerning because many are living on fixed incomes and may own older homes that are more expensive to insure.

Understanding What Affects Your Premium

As a senior homeowner in Florida, several factors determine how much you’ll pay for insurance:

Factors You Can’t Control

• Your home’s location and proximity to the coast
• Local weather patterns and hurricane risk
• Your neighborhood’s claims history
• Age of your home

Factors You CAN Influence

• Your roof’s age and material – A newer roof, especially one with impact-resistant materials, can significantly reduce premiums
• Wind mitigation features – Hurricane shutters, impact windows, and reinforced garage doors can earn substantial discounts
• Home maintenance – Keeping your electrical, plumbing, and HVAC systems updated
• Security systems – Monitored alarm systems may qualify for discounts
• Claims history – Avoiding small claims when possible helps keep rates lower

Important Home-Buying Considerations for Seniors

If you’re considering purchasing a home in Florida during retirement, here are crucial insurance-related questions to ask before making an offer:

1. When was the roof last replaced? Roofs older than 15-20 years may be difficult or expensive to insure
2. What type of plumbing does the home have? Polybutylene or galvanized pipes can increase premiums
3. Is the electrical system up to code? Older electrical systems, especially aluminum wiring, are red flags for insurers
4. What flood zone is the property in? This affects both flood insurance requirements and availability
5. What insurance company currently covers the home? This gives you insight into insurability
6. Are there any recent insurance claims on the property? Previous claims can affect future coverage options

Always get an insurance quote before finalizing any home purchase. Some properties may be uninsurable or prohibitively expensive to insure.

Citizens Insurance: What Seniors Should Know

Many Florida seniors are finding themselves with Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, the state-run “insurer of last resort.” While this might sound concerning, here’s what you need to know:

What Citizens Is

• A state-run insurance company created to provide coverage when private insurers won’t
• Not a sign that you’re getting inferior coverage—it’s legitimate insurance
• Often the most affordable option available

Things to Consider

• Rate increases: Citizens can raise rates, sometimes significantly, though there are legislative protections
• Assessments: If Citizens faces large losses, all Florida property owners (including those with private insurance) may face special assessments
• Depopulation: Citizens actively tries to move customers back to private insurers when possible, and as of 2025 it’s becoming a more viable alternative. Check into your options.

Bottom line: If you end up with Citizens, you’re still properly insured. It’s not ideal long-term, but it’s a reliable safety net while the market stabilizes.

Flood Insurance: A Critical Consideration

One of the biggest misconceptions among homeowners—especially seniors new to Florida—is about flood insurance.

Key Facts About Flood Insurance

• Not included in standard homeowners insurance policies
• Available to everyone, regardless of flood zone
• 30-day waiting period before coverage takes effect, so don’t wait until a storm is approaching
• Covers both building and contents, but requires separate coverage for each

FEMA’s Risk Rating 2.0

The federal flood insurance program recently updated how it calculates risk and premiums. This means:

• Some properties will see lower rates
• Others may face significant increases
• Rates now consider more factors than just flood zone maps

Senior-specific advice: Even if you’re not in a designated flood zone, consider flood insurance. Florida’s flat terrain, combined with heavy rainfall and storm surge, can cause flooding anywhere, and it has. The peace of mind is often worth the cost, which can be as low as a few hundred dollars annually.

Practical Tips for Florida Seniors

Managing Insurance Costs

1. Shop around annually – The insurance landscape changes rapidly in Florida
2. Work with a licensed agent – They know which companies are writing policies and can find options you might miss
3. Consider higher deductibles – If you can afford a higher out-of-pocket expense, this can lower premiums significantly
4. Bundle policies – Auto and home insurance with the same company often provides discounts
5. Ask about senior discounts – Many insurers offer age-based discounts

Protecting Your Investment

1. Maintain detailed home inventory – Document your possessions with photos and receipts
2. Keep maintenance records – Proof of regular upkeep can help with claims
3. Understand your coverage – Know what’s covered, what’s not, and what your deductibles are
4. Create an emergency fund – Having money set aside for deductibles and temporary living expenses is crucial

Planning for the Future

1. Review coverage annually – Your needs may change as you age
2. Consider long-term care implications – How might future care needs affect your housing situation?
3. Communicate with family – Make sure adult children understand your insurance situation and have access to policy information

Red Flags to Watch For

Be cautious of:

• Door-to-door insurance salespeople – Always verify credentials
• Unusually low quotes – If it seems too good to be true, it probably is
• Pressure to sign immediately – Legitimate agents will give you time to consider options
• Companies you’ve never heard of – Stick with rated, established insurers when possible

Looking Ahead: Reasons for Optimism

While Florida’s insurance market faces challenges, there are positive developments:

• Legislative reforms aimed at reducing litigation and stabilizing the market
• New technologies helping insurers better assess and price risk
• Innovation in construction making homes more resilient to storms
• Market corrections that, while painful short-term, should lead to more stability

Getting Help

If you’re feeling overwhelmed by Florida’s insurance market, remember:

• Licensed insurance agents are your best resource for current market conditions
• The Florida Department of Financial Services offers consumer resources and can help with complaints
• Local senior centers often host insurance education seminars
• Family members can help research options and advocate on your behalf

Final Thoughts

Florida’s insurance challenges are real, but they don’t have to derail your retirement plans. By staying informed, working with knowledgeable professionals, and making smart choices about home maintenance and coverage, you can protect your home and financial security.

Remember: the goal isn’t to find the cheapest insurance—it’s to find reliable, adequate coverage at a price you can afford. In Florida’s current market, that may require patience, flexibility, and professional guidance, but it’s absolutely achievable.

The Sunshine State still offers tremendous benefits for retirees, from no state income tax to year-round outdoor activities. Don’t let insurance concerns overshadow these advantages—just make sure you’re prepared and properly protected.

---

Have questions about Florida homeowners insurance? Consider consulting with a licensed insurance professional who understands the unique challenges facing Florida seniors. Jude Creamer has multiple trustworthy and knowledgeable insurance professionals she can recommend. You can reach Jude at 404.610.2907 or at Jude@JudeCreamer.com